Be nice to geologists

Well, I have been taken to the woodshed by my many geologist friends for using the word “geologist” to describe those who use the Periodic Table to guide their expectations, which in turn are key to deciding whether or not a result is viewed as “extraordinary”, in the Sagan sense.

My bad. And to think of it, more correct for such folks would be the word “chemist”. After all, the Periodic Table is at the core of chemistry. Further, those whose work in geology departments centers on the Table might call themselves “geochemists”, to distinguish themselves from those whose work centers on hiking landscapes to plot strata.

Now, anyone who finds the string c-h-e-m-i-s-t somewhere in their CV does not a priori find it absurd to propose that an element below another element in the Table might substitute for an element above. Especially organic chemists. Indeed, the “halogen series” of compounds (fluorine replaced by chlorine replaced by bromine replaced by iodine) is a staple of physical organic chemistry; the changing reactivity of one set of compounds along that series is used to calibrate changing reactivity for many other sets.

This is even true for elements in the middle of the Table. People who base expectations using the Periodic Table (shall we call them X-chemists?) do not discard generally as absurd the notion that silicon might substitute for carbon in some contexts, or arsenic might substitute for phosphorus, with “trend-like” changes in behavior.

But Sagan’s aphorism (“extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence”) was the focus of my comment, not the naming of fields. It is not easily applied, as “extraordinary” depends on context. If all that you know about chemistry is the Periodic Table, the claim of arsenate DNA might not strike you as requiring extraordinary evidence. Only if you know much more chemistry does this change.


  1. Kari says:

    I adore foregathering utile information, this
    post has got me even more info!

  2. writes in the official Makeup Bookmarking blog

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  3. Luv Issues says:

    Luv Issues

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  4. login winlotre

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  5. Welcome to Tyler Wagner: Allstate Insurance, the leading insurance agency located in Las Vegas, NV.
    With years of experience in the insurance industry, Tyler
    Wagner and his team are dedicated to providing exceptional customer service and tailored insurance solutions.

    From auto insurance to home insurance, to life and business insurance, Tyler Wagner:
    Allstate Insurance has your back. Our diverse
    coverage options guarantees that you can find the perfect policy to protect what matters most.

    Understanding the need for risk assessment, our team works diligently to offer personalized insurance quotes that are tailored to your specific needs.
    By leveraging our expertise in the insurance market and state-of-the-art underwriting processes, we ensure that you
    receive fair premium calculations.

    Navigating insurance claims can be a daunting task, but
    with Tyler Wagner: Allstate Insurance by your side,
    it’s expert guidance. Our streamlined claims processing system and
    supportive customer service team make sure that your claims are processed efficiently and compassionately.

    Moreover, we are deeply knowledgeable about insurance law and regulation, guaranteeing that your coverage is consistently
    in compliance with current legal standards. Our knowledge
    offers an added layer of security to our policyholders, assuring them that their insurance is robust and dependable.

    Our agency, we believe that insurance is more than just a policy.
    It’s a critical tool for protecting your future and
    securing the well-being of those you care about. Therefore, our team make it our mission to
    understand your individual needs and guide you through the selection of insurance options, ensuring that you are well-informed and comfortable
    with your decisions.

    Selecting Tyler Wagner: Allstate Insurance means choosing a
    reliable insurance broker in Las Vegas, NV, who values relationships and excellence.
    Our team isn’t just here to sell policies; we’re your partners in building a secure future.

    So, don’t hesitate to reach out today and discover how Tyler Wagner:
    Allstate Insurance can transform your insurance experience in Las Vegas, NV.

    Let us show you the difference of working with an insurance
    agency that genuinely cares about your needs and works tirelessly to securing your peace
    of mind.

Leave a Reply

  • About "A Tempting Science"

    Steven BennerSteven Benner discusses recent events in science and how they force us to think about how science is done. For information about Steven Benner’s career, research goals, and publications, please view his biosketch.

  • Life, the Universe...

    Look inside Life, the Universe, and the Scientific MethodLife, the Universe, and the Scientific Method discusses cross-disciplinary science to explain how scientists approach “big” questions, here, whether alien life might exist. With full color graphics and two dozen cartoons done by Jake Fuller, this is a must read for those interested in how science really works. As a limited time special offer for visiting our website, an autographed copy of the book can be purchased for a reduced price; visit for details.

We thank NASA and STScI for the image of the Milky Way.