Be nice to geologists

Well, I have been taken to the woodshed by my many geologist friends for using the word “geologist” to describe those who use the Periodic Table to guide their expectations, which in turn are key to deciding whether or not a result is viewed as “extraordinary”, in the Sagan sense.

My bad. And to think of it, more correct for such folks would be the word “chemist”. After all, the Periodic Table is at the core of chemistry. Further, those whose work in geology departments centers on the Table might call themselves “geochemists”, to distinguish themselves from those whose work centers on hiking landscapes to plot strata.

Now, anyone who finds the string c-h-e-m-i-s-t somewhere in their CV does not a priori find it absurd to propose that an element below another element in the Table might substitute for an element above. Especially organic chemists. Indeed, the “halogen series” of compounds (fluorine replaced by chlorine replaced by bromine replaced by iodine) is a staple of physical organic chemistry; the changing reactivity of one set of compounds along that series is used to calibrate changing reactivity for many other sets.

This is even true for elements in the middle of the Table. People who base expectations using the Periodic Table (shall we call them X-chemists?) do not discard generally as absurd the notion that silicon might substitute for carbon in some contexts, or arsenic might substitute for phosphorus, with “trend-like” changes in behavior.

But Sagan’s aphorism (“extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence”) was the focus of my comment, not the naming of fields. It is not easily applied, as “extraordinary” depends on context. If all that you know about chemistry is the Periodic Table, the claim of arsenate DNA might not strike you as requiring extraordinary evidence. Only if you know much more chemistry does this change.

159 Comments

  1. Jego rodzicami byli Richard i Kathie Wright.

  2. Slot games are one of the most popular gambling games
    in the sum up world, why ?. The slot robot was originally made as entertainment for bars
    or pubs in additional York. Players total coins and later tug the lever to spin the slot robot and the results that come out will determine what rewards the player
    gets from beer to cigar. The prize is distinct by the robot owner and there is no solution payment along with the machines.

    Then this was developed in accordance past the times,
    until finally gambling was acceptable in the associated States and many gambling houses or
    casinos made various types of slot games that existed
    until progressive in the tardy 20th century, several software companies made programs for the slot
    games we played today. This is upon an online gambling site.

    At gift there are more than hundreds of thousands of types of online slot games
    that exist throughout the world, made by thousands of gambling game software companies.
    However, there are several companies that are famous for the games
    they have developed that have fascinating graphics and sounds.
    under we will write a number of famous slot gambling
    software providers or developers, along next the most well-liked
    slot games from that slot provider.

  3. electric snow shovel cordless

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  4. Amazon Pressure Washers For Sale

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  5. amazon cell phones and accessories

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  6. used musical instruments for sale near me

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  7. hotukdeals ps4 console

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  8. harvest crunch nutrition label

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  9. earthquake ice auger

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  10. clearance luggage sets

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  11. photometer calibration

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  12. cake decorating tools supplies

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  13. via Genusswanderungen

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  14. top rated air fryer

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  15. portable generators near king nc

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  16. voip telephone reviews

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  17. milwaukee weed trimmer string

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  18. cub cadet snow blower

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  19. visit here says:

    visit here

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  20. best rated cordless string trimmers

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  21. cheap video Game chairs

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  22. Scholarship says:

    Scholarship

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  23. taglie scarpe

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  24. audew jump starter for sale

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  25. milwaukee quik-lok string trimmer attachment

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  26. tv ok odl 32677hn-tb recensioni

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  27. 500 lbs says:

    500 lbs

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  28. extra large tote bags for travel

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  29. cultured marble shower walls

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  30. click over here

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  31. nordmende nd55ks4300s – smart tv uhd 55 recensione

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  32. drill bits for tile

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  33. hp 22-df0061nl desktop all-in-one pc touch

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  34. ninja air fryer xl

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  35. snow blowers on sale

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  36. consumer reports handheld vacuums

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  37. cordless electric leaf blowers

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  38. earthquake 2 man auger

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  39. planet eclipse etha 3

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  40. Computer Portatili Offerte

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  41. best drill bits

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  42. Orologi uomo marche

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  43. mamamoo moonbyul selfish album sales

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  44. what do you think

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  45. shein abbigliamento

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  46. architecture and design magazine

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  47. pantaloncini Da Mare uomo

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  48. vintage smiths car clock

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  49. adidas walking shoes mens

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  50. homemade hair treatment with essential oils for dry hair

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  51. how to Increase volume on tozo t6

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  52. asda tvs 50 inch

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  53. airport body scanners images

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  54. i Videogiochi fanno Male

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  55. car stereo receivers carplay

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  56. Read zhulidianshang.com

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  57. Contenitori cucina ikea

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  58. home depot home generators

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  59. old plug and play tv games

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  60. troy bilt riding lawn mowers

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  61. from Nishisui

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  62. fruit dip with cream cheese and marshmallow fluff

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  63. solar portable power station

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  64. pete the cat apparel

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  65. see page says:

    see page

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  66. ebook readers canada

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  67. ranch salad dressing

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  68. richard pryor stand up dvds

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  69. how do string trimmers work

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  70. plates tableware

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  71. offerta smartphone

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  72. pantaloncini da Surf uomo

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  73. 4 strings bass guitar chords

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  74. orologi uomo svizzeri

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  75. attachment capable string trimmers

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  76. zaini porta pc carpisa

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  77. visit this site

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  78. motivi abbigliamento

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  79. recent post by Burningshenanigans

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  80. Kitchen cooktops India

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  81. her explanation

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  82. hatsan hydra says:

    hatsan hydra

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  83. napkins – bundle for 16

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  84. the ultimate optics guide to rifle shooting pdf

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  85. what items are not allowed On a Plane in hand luggage

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  86. canadian pet supplies

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  87. hard skills for business office manager

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  88. biscuit mix recipe

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  89. makita compact router

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  90. soft slouchy leather hobo bags

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  91. love it says:

    love it

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  92. ge book lights

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  93. dry shampoo for black hair

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  94. sea dragon pets

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  95. snow blower sales

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  96. 3 hp water pumps

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  97. planet eclipse paintball gun for sale

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  98. pioneer audio video multi channel receiver vsx 516

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  99. Air Fryer 6 Qt

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  100. televisions near me

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  101. cell phone car chargers multi Phones

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  102. how to make curry sauce

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  103. zgemma set up

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  104. periodic table wallpaper

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  105. Tc Yexian 0375 blog post

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  106. squier p bass electric guitar

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  107. designer travel tote

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  108. leather satchel women’s

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  109. women’s clothing store near me

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  110. ysl cassandra top handle bag

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  111. handle bar bag

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  112. leather satchel backpacks

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  113. davina mccall fitness app

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  114. fendi handbags

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  115. size 16 women’s clothing

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  116. Check This Out

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  117. Lands End Women’s Clothing

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  118. lv top handle bag

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  119. husqvarna 235 chainsaw

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  120. Chanel flap bag with handle

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  121. davina mccall new fitness dvd

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  122. quiz women’s clothing

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  123. asian cinema movies

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  124. additional reading

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  125. davina mccall fat

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  126. creative wallpaper periodic table

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  127. mcbrine luggage review

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  128. best crossbody bags

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  129. visit Talentium`s official website

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  130. Kruseparkchiro website

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  131. davina mccall workout reviews

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  132. hatsan vortex air rifles

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  133. Luggage Sets On sale canada

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  134. hatsan air rifles who makes them

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  135. makita 7 inch angle grinder

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  136. electriq tv brand

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  137. Makita Battery Angle Grinder

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  138. Suggested Studying

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  139. leather wallet for women

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  140. Going in Tysonschance

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  141. bdsm sex Toys

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  142. leather small wallet

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  143. go to Schlager Wiki

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  144. best leather wallet for women

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  145. electriq tv manufacturer

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  146. general digital caliper

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  147. zte v55 tablet

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  148. electriq tv review

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  149. computer Art tablets

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  150. generac 6922 pressure washer

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  151. artego parrucchieri

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  152. wood milling machine

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  153. davina tone in 10

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  154. vintage tobacco pipes

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  155. Ariat Women’s clothing

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  156. football.ll.land official

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  157. recent post by Importationwealth

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  158. riviste videogiochi

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

  159. cute crossbody bags

    Be nice to geologists « A Tempting Science

Leave a Reply

  • About "A Tempting Science"

    Steven BennerSteven Benner discusses recent events in science and how they force us to think about how science is done. For information about Steven Benner’s career, research goals, and publications, please view his biosketch.

  • Life, the Universe...

    Look inside Life, the Universe, and the Scientific MethodLife, the Universe, and the Scientific Method discusses cross-disciplinary science to explain how scientists approach “big” questions, here, whether alien life might exist. With full color graphics and two dozen cartoons done by Jake Fuller, this is a must read for those interested in how science really works. As a limited time special offer for visiting our website, an autographed copy of the book can be purchased for a reduced price; visit ffame.org for details.

We thank NASA and STScI for the image of the Milky Way.